Skip to main content

Whoa! What have we got here? An indie music enthusiast seeking some of the finest gems in the genre? Oh, honey, it’s your lucky day. Gather round, children, and get ready for an exquisitely curated list of the 10 must-listen indie music albums! We’ve got something for everyone, especially for a fan of The Mountain Goats, Amigo the Devil, and Covey. Put your headphones on, and let’s dive headfirst into this sparkling pool of indie delights!

1. “All Hail West Texas” by – yep you guessed it – The Mountain Goats. You love ’em already, so why not start with a class act of close-knit, fireside storytelling that’ll leave you craving for marshmallows? Each track on this album feels like a short story, narrating the tales of those living in the titular state. It’s personal, intimate, and showcases John Darnielle’s prowess as a storyteller.

2. “Everything That Dies” by Covey. Ah! Straight up paradise for those who swim in the depths of relentlessly honest songwriting. Speak of pain, heartbreak, renewal, survival; this album doesn’t shy away from exposing it all. This is the album when you’re rolling down the highway, the setting sun in your rearview mirror, and reality hits you.

3. “If We Make It Through December” by Phoebe Bridgers. If you are fan of the confessional, raw emotion from Amigo the Devil and Covey, then this one will resonate. Phoebe’s staple emotional exploration is at the forefront in this EP, serving indie folk sprinkled with modern-day Americana.

4. “The Suburbs” by Arcade Fire. This one is a Grammy winner, baby! A concept album based on nostalgia, lost youth, and American dreams. It’s like a Picasso painting – you gotta spend some time, soak in the details, and then you’d see the grand picture emerge.

5. “Boxer” by The National. This one’s like a tasting plate – a bit of rock, a bit of folk, a touch of alternative, garnished with swooning baritone vocals. Mmmmm! Not to mention, Boxer delivers powerful lyrics that can make you brood over life’s intricacies.

6. “Sprained Ankle” by Julien Baker. Oh boy, oh boy, are you prepared to dabble in some tear-soaked sheets of confessional indie rock? This sucker punch of an album is profoundly intimate and reveals the vulnerability of the singer in grand fashion.

7. “An Awesome Wave” by Alt-J. This record, my good friend, is part indie rock, part folk, and part I-don’t-know-what-but-it-sounds-awesome. Delving into everything from fragile love to human consciousness, it’s an album for silent contemplation. The trio’s playful experimentation with sounds is worth experiencing.

8. “Punisher” by Phoebe Bridgers. You might argue, “Two times the same artist, Genie?” But honey, this isn’t just any artist, it’s Phoebe Bridgers we’re talking about! This album plays like a diary filled with emotional self-explorations and dark humor, and it’s got just about everything you need for a cozy evening of introspection.

9. “Days” by Real Estate. This is a dream pop/indie rock delicacy you simply cannot ignore. It’s got laid back tunes perfect for a breezy summer day as you’re sipping lemonade on your porch. Its easygoing nature masks the complexity of emotions within.

10. “In the Aeroplane Over the Sea” by Neutral Milk Hotel. This one’s a cult classic! It’s folksy, it’s lo-fi, it’s indie rock at its grainiest. Full of eclectic instruments and surrealistic lyrics, this album is as intriguing as it is enchanting.

So there you have it, folks! A smorgasbord of indie goodness awaits your ears in these ten delightful albums. And the best part? There’s something for every mood and moment. But if I had to pick one, just one that you should start with, I’d say go with “All Hail West Texas” by The Mountain Goats.

Why, you ask? Well, my friend, it’s like going back to your roots. As a fan of The Mountain Goats, this album presents John Darnielle’s storytelling at its finest, raw and unadulterated. It’s a simple yet profound journey filled with fascinating characters and a picturesque analysis of existence. By exploring this album first, you get to experience where it all started for you and sets a benchmark for you to compare and enjoy the other albums. Happy listening, my friend! And remember, no matter the genre or the artist, it’s all about the ride on this magical carpet called music!

Find More Music
Back To Genre Genie